Key Takeaways
- In Pennsylvania, you generally have one year from the Register of Wills’ decree to contest a will, although the court can shorten this period to three months (20 Pa.C.S. § 908).
- Only a “party in interest” can contest, which is someone who would receive more if the will were set aside.
- Common grounds for challenging a will include lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, forgery, and improper execution.
- Pennsylvania courts generally won’t enforce a no-contest clause if the person challenging the will had probable cause to do so (20 Pa.C.S. § 2521).
You’ve recently lost a parent, and something about their will doesn’t seem right. Perhaps they previously promised to divide their estate equally among their children, but a last-minute change left nearly everything to one sibling. Or maybe a new will appeared shortly before their death, raising questions about whether they fully understood what they were signing.
Alternatively, you may be an executor facing a challenge from a family member who believes the will is invalid.
Whether you’re challenging a will or defending one, Pennsylvania imposes strict deadlines and specific legal requirements. Understanding how these disputes work can help you protect your interests and determine your next steps.
What Does It Mean to Contest a Will in Pennsylvania?
Contesting a will means challenging its legal validity. However, believing a will is unfair isn’t enough to have it overturned. Pennsylvania law generally allows individuals to decide who inherits their property, even if that means excluding certain family members. You must have a legally recognized reason to challenge the will, such as evidence that the deceased person lacked the mental capacity to make it or was pressured into changing their wishes.
Most will contests begin after the county Register of Wills accepts the will for probate. Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 908, an eligible individual can appeal that decision to the Orphans’ Court Division of the county Court of Common Pleas.
If the court determines that the will is invalid, an earlier valid will may govern how the estate is distributed. If no valid will exists, Pennsylvania’s intestacy laws determine who inherits the property. Learn what happens if you die without a will in Pennsylvania.
Who Can Contest a Will in Pennsylvania?
Not everyone has the legal right to challenge a will. In Pennsylvania, you must qualify as a “party in interest,” which generally means you would inherit more if the will were invalidated.
For example, a child excluded from a recently revised will may have grounds to contest it if they would inherit under an earlier version. However, if the earlier will also excluded them, successfully challenging the newer document may not change their inheritance.
At Bumbaugh | George | Prather | DeDiana, one of the first things we evaluate is whether a potential challenger has the legal standing to pursue a contest and what they could realistically gain from the outcome.
What is the Deadline to Contest a Will in PA?
Pennsylvania imposes strict deadlines on will contests. The applicable timeline depends on whether the Register of Wills has already admitted the will to probate.
Before Probate: Filing a Caveat
If you believe a will is invalid but it hasn’t been admitted to probate, you may be able to file a caveat with the Register of Wills. A caveat is a formal written objection requesting that the Register delay probate until the concerns about the will can be addressed.
Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 906, the Register generally cannot delay probate for more than 10 days based on a caveat unless an interested party posts a bond between $500 and $5,000.
After Probate: The One-Year Appeal Period
Once the Register of Wills admits a will to probate, an eligible party generally has one year from the Register’s decree to file an appeal with the Orphans’ Court. However, the court can shorten this appeal period to three months if an interested party petitions for a shorter deadline.
When Does the Deadline Begin?
Under Pennsylvania Orphans’ Court Rule 10.5, the executor must generally send a Notice of Estate Administration to designated interested parties within three months after receiving authorization to administer the estate. This notice informs beneficiaries and certain family members that estate administration has begun.
The one-year appeal period generally begins when the Register issues the probate decree, not when you receive the notice. If you have concerns about a will’s validity, speaking with an attorney promptly can help you avoid missing an important filing deadline.
What Are the Legal Grounds for Contesting a Will in Pennsylvania?
You can’t successfully challenge a will simply because you disagree with its terms. Pennsylvania courts require evidence supporting a recognized legal ground for invalidating the document.
Some of the most common grounds include:
| Ground | What Must Be Shown | Typical Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Lack of testamentary capacity | The person didn’t have the mental capacity to understand their will when they signed it. | Medical records, caregiver observations, and testimony from the attorney who prepared the will. |
| Undue influence | Someone improperly pressured or manipulated the person into making or changing their will. | Sudden changes benefiting a caregiver, evidence of dependence, and involvement in preparing the will. |
| Fraud | Someone deceived the person into signing a will or changing their estate plans. | False statements, misleading information, or misrepresented documents. |
| Forgery | Someone forged the person’s signature on the will. | Handwriting analysis and testimony questioning the signature’s authenticity. |
| Improper execution | The will doesn’t meet Pennsylvania’s legal requirements for a valid document. | The original will, signature details, and relevant witness testimony. |
| Revocation or later will | The person revoked the will or replaced it with a newer valid document. | A subsequent will, codicil, or evidence of revocation. |
Testamentary Capacity
Pennsylvania courts generally presume that someone had the mental capacity to create a valid will, so the person challenging it must provide evidence to the contrary. The key question is whether the individual understood their family relationships, the general nature of their property, and how their will would distribute their assets when they signed it. Age, illness, or forgetfulness alone isn’t enough to invalidate a will.
Undue Influence in Pennsylvania
Undue influence occurs when someone exerts pressure that overrides another person’s free will. To establish undue influence, the person challenging the will must generally demonstrate three elements through clear and convincing evidence:
- Weakened intellect of the person making the will
- A confidential relationship between the person and beneficiary
- A substantial benefit to the beneficiary
If all three elements are established, the burden shifts to the person defending the will to prove that undue influence did not occur. At Bumbaugh | George | Prather | DeDiana, we can examine the circumstances surrounding the will’s creation, including who scheduled the appointment, who selected the attorney, and how the new will differs from previous estate plans.
Execution Requirements
A Pennsylvania will must be in writing and signed at the end (20 Pa.C.S. § 2502); witnesses are not required when the testator signs. However, under 20 Pa.C.S. § 3132, two witnesses must prove the will at probate. A self-proving affidavit under 20 Pa.C.S. § 3132.1 can satisfy this requirement without additional witness testimony unless the will is contested. See our last will and testament overview for more information.
What Happens During a Pennsylvania Will Contest?
Once an eligible party files an appeal, the case proceeds through the Orphans’ Court Division of the county Court of Common Pleas. The court generally issues a formal notice directing the executor and other interested parties to respond.
Depending on the circumstances, the process may involve:
- Gathering evidence: Both sides review relevant records, including medical documents, previous wills, and the drafting attorney’s files.
- Depositions and testimony: Attorneys may question witnesses, beneficiaries, medical professionals, and others who have relevant information.
- Settlement discussions or mediation: The parties may attempt to resolve the dispute without a contested court hearing.
- Court hearing: If the parties can’t reach an agreement, an Orphans’ Court judge will evaluate the evidence and determine whether the will is valid.
How Long Does a Will Contest Take?
The timeline depends on the complexity of the dispute, the available evidence, and whether the parties can reach a settlement. Some cases resolve within a few months through negotiation or mediation, while more complicated disputes may take a year or longer.
While a will contest can take months or longer to resolve, filing an appeal doesn’t automatically pause estate administration. Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 908(c), the executor generally retains the authority to manage the estate while the dispute proceeds.
Can a No-Contest Clause Prevent You From Challenging a Will?
Some Pennsylvania wills contain a no-contest clause, sometimes called an in terrorem clause. This provision states that a beneficiary may lose their inheritance if they challenge the will.
However, Pennsylvania law places limits on these provisions. Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 2521, a no-contest clause is unenforceable if the person challenging the will had probable cause to pursue the contest.
Since the financial consequences of contesting a will can be significant, it’s a good idea to speak with an estate attorney before filing a challenge involving this type of provision.
Will Contests in Westmoreland, Allegheny, and Fayette Counties
In Pennsylvania, will contests generally proceed in the county where the deceased person lived. For families in Southwestern Pennsylvania, the relevant county offices include:
- Westmoreland County: The Register of Wills and Orphans’ Court Division at the county courthouse in Greensburg.
- Allegheny County: The Register of Wills and Orphans’ Court Division in downtown Pittsburgh.
- Fayette County: The Register of Wills and Orphans’ Court Division at the county courthouse in Uniontown.
While Pennsylvania law establishes the general framework for will contests, each county has its own local court procedures and filing requirements.
Bumbaugh | George | Prather | DeDiana assists clients with estate matters throughout Westmoreland, Allegheny, and Fayette Counties from our Irwin office. Our familiarity with these local courts helps us guide clients through the procedural requirements of challenging or defending a will.
A Real-World Example
A widowed Westmoreland County father signed a new will eight weeks before death, leaving his home to the daughter caring for him, rather than dividing the property equally among his three children as his previous will specified. His two sons learn about the change after receiving the Notice of Estate Administration.
Medical records reveal that their father had been diagnosed with dementia, and the daughter had arranged the appointment with an attorney who was unfamiliar with the family’s previous estate plans. Concerned about their father’s mental capacity and the possibility of undue influence, the sons consult an attorney and file a challenge within the applicable deadline.
During the legal process, both sides review medical records, attorney communications, and other evidence. They ultimately reach a settlement without proceeding to a court hearing.
When Should You Speak With an Attorney About a Will Contest?
Will contests can involve complicated family relationships, financial interests, and legal questions. Whether you’re considering challenging a will or defending one, early legal guidance can help you understand your rights and avoid costly mistakes.
Consider speaking with a Pennsylvania estate attorney if:
- You believe a will is invalid and want to object before it enters probate.
- You received a Notice of Estate Administration and have concerns about the will’s terms or validity.
- The deceased person changed their will shortly before death while experiencing illness or increased dependence on a beneficiary.
- You’re an executor facing a challenge from a family member who questions the will’s validity.
Defending the will is also part of an executor’s role (see duties of an executor in Pennsylvania). When an executor brings us a threatened contest, Bumbaugh | George | Prather | DeDiana gathers the drafting file and witness information while memories are still fresh.
If you believe a loved one’s will is invalid or you’re an executor facing a potential challenge, you don’t have to navigate the legal process alone. Our estate attorneys can review the will, evaluate the circumstances surrounding its creation, and help you understand your options before important deadlines pass.
Schedule an estate planning consultation with Bumbaugh | George | Prather | DeDiana to discuss your concerns and determine the appropriate next steps.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do you have to contest a will in Pennsylvania?
In Pennsylvania, you generally have one year from the Register of Wills’ decree to appeal a will’s admission to probate under 20 Pa.C.S. § 908. However, the Orphans’ Court may shorten the appeal period to three months if an interested party petitions for a shorter deadline.
Who can contest a will in Pennsylvania?
Generally, only a person with a legal financial interest in the outcome can contest a will. This may include children, heirs, or beneficiaries who would inherit more under an earlier valid will or Pennsylvania’s intestacy laws.
How do you prove undue influence on a will in Pennsylvania?
To prove undue influence on a Pennsylvania will, a contestant generally must establish three elements through clear and convincing evidence: weakened intellect, a confidential relationship with the beneficiary, and a substantial benefit to that beneficiary. If these elements are established, the burden shifts to the person defending the will to demonstrate that undue influence did not occur.
What is a caveat in Pennsylvania probate?
A caveat is a written objection requesting that the Register of Wills delay admitting a will to probate. Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 906, the Register generally can’t delay probate for more than 10 days based on a caveat unless an interested party posts a bond between $500 and $5,000.
Does a no-contest clause stop you from challenging a will in Pennsylvania?
Not necessarily. Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 2521, a no-contest clause generally can’t penalize a beneficiary who had probable cause to challenge the will. However, contesting a will without sufficient legal grounds could put an inheritance at risk.
How long does a will contest take in Pennsylvania?
Some Pennsylvania will contests resolve within a few months through negotiation or mediation, while more complicated disputes may take a year or longer. The timeline depends on the available evidence, the number of parties involved, and whether the case requires a contested court hearing.




